Download File Game

General Court confirms that body builder silhouette cannot be registered as a trade mark for nutritional supplements

The body-builder silhouette

Can “a silhouette, represented in black, of a person adopting a typical body-building pose displaying the muscles of his body” be registered as a trade mark for – among other things – nutritional supplements, clothing, and footwear?

As Katfriend Nedim Malovic (@malovicSE) explains, this very question has been recently addressed by the General Court.

Here’s what Nedim writes:

“In its judgmenton 29 September 2016 (Universal Protein Supplements Corp v European Union Intellectual Property Office Case, T-335/15, EU:T:2016:579) the General Court upheld the decision of the Fifth Board of Appeal of the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) concerning an application to register a figurative sign representing a body-builder as a EU trade mark for the following classes of goods and services, and descriptions:

      Class 5: ‘Nutritional supplements’;
Class 25: ‘Clothing; footwear’;
Class 35: ‘On-line retail store services featuring nutritional supplements; health and diet-related products; clothing and footwear’.

Background

In 2014 the applicant, Universal Protein Supplements Corp, filed an application with the EUIPO to have the EU territory designed in respect of the international registration of a figurative sign representing a body-builder. The application was for goods and services in the classes indicated above.

The EUIPO examiner rejected the application, on grounds that the mark lacked any distinctive character and was descriptive for the purpose of Article 7(1)(c) of Regulation No 207/2009 on the (now) European Union Trade Mark (EUTMR).

In late 2014 Universal Protein appealed the examiner’s decision.

The EUIPO Fifth Board of Appeal dismissed the appeal in March 2015. It held that the message conveyed by the sign related to ‘body-building’ or a ‘body-builder’ and that the relevant public would perceive a direct and specific link between the sign and the goods and services designated by the mark applied for.

The Board of Appeal concluded that such mark fell within the prohibition laid down in Article 7(1)(c) EUTMR. Furthermore, the mark was devoid of any distinctive character within the meaning of Article 7(1) (b) EUTMR, on the ground that it merely consisted of a representation of a body-builder, which would not enable the relevant public to perceive it as an indication of the commercial origin of the goods and services in question. 

Universal Protein did not however lose hope, and decided to appeal the decision before the General Court.  It claimed that: (i) the Fifth Board of Appeal had failed to consider the mark as a whole; (ii) that its own image of the body-builder has several meanings and conveys a message that goes beyond that of a ‘body-builder’ or ‘body-building’, and (iii) that securing registration would not impair the public interest aim that descriptive signs are not monopolised by economic operators.  

The National Lottery silhouette

Analysis

The General court began by examining whether Universal Protein’s mark should be considered descriptive.  

Article 7(1)(c) EUTMR pursues a public interest aim. Referring to Agencja Wydawnicza Technopol, the court recalled that a sign that is descriptive of the characteristics of the relevant goods or services ought to be freely available for use. In addition, a sign of this kind fails to fulfil the essential function of a trade mark, ie to identify the commercial origin of one’s own goods or services.

The General Court then stated that the descriptive nature of a sign is only to be assessed, (1) by reference to the way in which it is perceived by the relevant public, and (2) by reference to the goods or services concerned:

(1) Having regard to the relevant goods and services (nutritional supplements, clothing, footwear and online retail services relating to those goods) and considering that the mark is strictly figurative and lacks any verbal element, the average consumer – obviously reasonably well informed and reasonably observant and circumspect – is the public of the entire European Union. This said, because the sign consists of a typical body-builder, displaying the muscles of his body, represented in black silhouette, the message conveyed by that sign would relate to body-building.

(2) The chosen goods and services in Classes 5 (nutritional supplements), 25 (clothing; footwear), and 35 (online retail store services featuring nutritional supplements; health and diet-related products; clothing and shoes), are all indicative that the mark applied for has a sufficiently direct and specific link with nutritional supplements, clothing, footwear, and online retail store services of those goods and goods related to health and diet. According to the court, even if the categories of goods and services at issue were to also include services with no link to body-building and that, accordingly, the sign at issue were not descriptive of all the goods and services in those categories, the applicant had applied for the registration of the sign at issue for each of these as a whole without making any distinction. Accordingly, the body-builder sign would fall within the prohibition set by Article 7(1)(c) EUTMR.

Contrary to the applicant’s claims, the court found that the alleged aesthetic character of the stylised image does not require any mental effort on behalf of the relevant public. The meaning of the sign at issue (which refers to the concept of ‘body-builder’ or ‘body-building’) is immediately clear.  By referring to earlier case law, the court added that, even assuming that a sign has several meanings, if at least one of the meanings designates a characteristic of the goods concerned, then that sign must be equally refused.

Merpels silhouette

The applicant’s further claim that there would be no general interest in requiring that a representation such as that in the present case be available because there are practically unlimited ways of depicting body-builders was regarded as irrelevant. In that respect, the court noted (as also previously stated by the EUIPO) that, according to settled case-law, the application of Article 7(1)(c) of the EUTMR does not depend on the existence of a real, current or serious need to leave a sign free. 

The Board of Appeal was therefore correct in concluding that the sign in question is descriptive for the purpose of Article 7(1)(c) EUTMR.

All this said, the court considered unnecessary to review whether the sign at issue would be distinctive, and concluded that the body-builder silhouette could not be registered as a trade mark because of the prohibition in Article 7(1)(c) EUTMR.

Conclusion

This decision appears correct from a formal standpoint, and probably the General Court was concerned with the implications of creating a monopoly over the use of a silhouette of this kind for such types of goods and services. However, in the past there have been decisions that could have supported a different outcome. For instance, it is unclear why the silhouette of a body-builder should be descriptive of nutritional supplements, while a hand with a smile and crossed fingers should not suggest “best of luck” and describe what the concept of lottery is all about. Yet, the National Lottery ‘hand’ was successfully registered as a EU trade mark.”

Go to link for download

Rejoice MTN Better Talk BT Subscribers As MTN Increases Bonus Airtime Recharge By 25

In the midst of bad news like in the recent increment on the prices of interest rate of http://tylercaldwellphotography.blogspot.com /2016/10/beware-mtn-increases-interest-rate-of.html" target="_blank">MTN extra-time credit and also the new increase in http://tylercaldwellphotography.blogspot.com /2016/10/sad-etisalat-increases-prices-of.html" target="_blank">Etisalat monthly data bundles, it is good to at least throw up some cheering news.

Now for those on http://tylercaldwellphotography.blogspot.com /2015/05/new-mtn-better-talk-plan-offers-200.html" target="_blank">MTN Better Talk call tariff plan, you have all cause to rejoice as MTN has recently increased the recharge bonus for all Better Talk subscribers from 200% to 250%, which implies a 25% increment.

And you should note that this is still applicable on all recharges from N100 and above.

For instance, if you now recharge with N100 airtime instead of getting N200 bonus airtime, you will be getting N250 and likewise in other recharges above N100.

In order to start enjoying this recharge bonus, you have to migrate to MTN Better Talk call tariff plan, and to do so, simply dial the migration code *123*2*6# then recharge your airtime after that.

Finally, you should remember that all calls on MTN Better Talk are charged at flat rate of 40K/S (N24/Min).

Go to link for download

Bradley Horowitz takes over as Product Head at Google Plus

Google+ is currently being going by Bradley Horowitz (a long-lasting VP of item for Google+), taking over David Besbris. The social network is likewise being part into Photos and Streams.

Besbris just assumed control Google+ not as much as a year prior, in April 2014, after Vic Gundotra — who had begun and driven Google+ since its initiation — left the organization (Source: ReCode).
 
The declaration comes only a few days after Googles senior VP of products Sundar Pichai said in an interview to Forbes, "I think progressively youll see us concentrate on correspondences, photos and the Google+ Stream as three vital zones, as opposed to being considered one region."
 
"Some incredible remarks from Sundar Pichai about future item heading for Google+, Photos, Hangouts," Horowitz composed on his G+ page. "Weve been buckling down on these progressions and Im truly amped up for what these will mean for our clients."

Notwithstanding differentiating photograph management from Google+, the organization will likewise separation its Hangouts correspondence stage from the social network, and build up every one of the three freely.

Itll be intriguing to see exactly how the move changes the Google+ experience for clients in the days to come.

Nobody was asked to leave, no teams were transferred, yet few (if anybody) were offered incentives to stick around, the source says. Individuals communicated concerns to management yet while Google was thoughtful, there was endeavor to attempt to persuade individuals to sit tight.

Its not clear what part Besbris will be taking next. Like Horowitz, he has been with Google since 2008.

Go to link for download

Ulefone Tiger – Powerful Fast and Beautiful as Tiger

Go to link for download

Four killed as youth attack Shiites in Kaduna

Bismillahi..

Irate youth in Tudun Wada community in Kaduna South Local Government Area, attacked and killed four suspected members of the Shi’a sect, and torched the residence of their group’s leader Wednesday, witnesses said.

The mob also demolished the Shiite’s Islamic school in the area.

The incident occurred a day after a clampdown by Nigerian security forces prevented the Shiites from embarking on their planned annual procession.

“It’s the police that ordered the youths to attack us and to destroy our buildings,” one Shiite leader told PREMIUM TIMES by phone. “We shall address a press conference to give account of our encounter later,” he said.

This newspaper learned that an attempt by the Shiites to address a press conference at the Nigeria Union of Journalists secretariat, was botched as all of the journalists went underground.

Mallam Bala, a shopowner at Zango road, said the angry youth prevented the Shiite members from entering their communities after being dispersed by police tear gas.

“They were not in their traditional black dress, while being dispersed with police tear gas, but were being identified by vigilant youths who engaged them in a fight. Those who resisted were killed; the house of their leader Mukhtar was burnt down and their Markas (school) is currently being demolished by youths,” he said.

He said fire service helped put out fire at Mukhtar’s house.

“The situation is under control,” a police source has confirmed to our reporter.

Bashir Sani, another resident of the area, said the youth broke into the Shiite leader’s house, carted away valuables before setting the house ablaze.

“The Shiite members died of injuries sustained while being lynched with sticks and machetes,” he said.

There was however, no official confirmation of the number of death.

Police spokesperson, Aliyu Muhammad, did not respond to calls and text messages.

The attack came a day after a standoff between soldiers and members of the group, outlawed last week by the Kaduna government.

Worshippers had gathered to commemorate historical events associated with the Islamic month of Muharram that are particularly significant in the Shia calendar, UK-based Islamic Human Rights Commission, said earlier Tuesday in a statement.

Later, the gathering was encircled by armed troops.

The standoff ended later in the night after the troops withdrew.

The military activity around the area earlier on Tuesday was reminiscent of the run-up to the massacre last December of hundreds of supporters of the Islamic Movement of Nigeria by the army and the arrest of its leader Sheikh Ibrahim Zakzaky.

Mr. Zakzaky remains in government custody.

One resident said Zango community members have always complained about the activities of the Shiite group gathering at Mr. Sahabi’s residence.

“For me I will never support violence but Sahabi’s house here is risky for us. Every evening they gather at his house singing hate songs against the governor and Buhari and even none Shiite people,” said the resident.

Go to link for download